honourable singh thank you very much for your support of the bill we would agree with you that the establishment of the budget office is something that will certainly assist parliament we would think that that resource should be well equipped both in terms of personnel and other technical resources we believe that that would enrich the process of interrogating the budget getting better accountability to parliament and getting parliamentarians more involved in this process as well we agree that there are areas of concern which you share with the honourable swart as well around mud schools money not being spent and outstanding land claims we agree with you on all of those issues as well but the problem is not to just point a finger in that direction we should